March 22, 2024

LLC vs S Corp: A Comprehensive Guide for Independent Contractors and Consultants

Pollen Team
This comprehensive guide explores the differences between LLCs and S Corps, providing valuable insights for independent contractors and consultants in making the right choice for their business structure.
LLC vs S Corp: A Comprehensive Guide for Independent Contractors and Consultants

Table of contents

Are you an independent contractor or consultant deliberating over the business structure for your venture? Have you found yourself caught up in the LLC vs S Corp debate? This guide aims to clarify the differences, benefits, and drawbacks of these two popular choices, helping you make an informed decision that suits your unique situation.

LLC and S Corp: What are they?

Before diving into the comparison, let's first understand what an LLC and an S Corp are.

An LLC, short for Limited Liability Company, is a type of business structure that offers its owners — referred to as members — limited personal liability for business debts. It's a popular choice among freelancers and consultants because it combines the flexibility of a partnership with the liability protection typically found in corporations. Many independent contractors appreciate the simplicity and flexibility offered by an LLC structure, as evidenced in the article, Why Do Independent Contractors Love the S Corps? Short ....

On the other hand, an S Corp, or Subchapter S Corporation, is a special type of corporation created through an IRS tax election. It allows the income, deductions, and credits of the corporation to pass through to shareholders for federal tax purposes. Essentially, this means that S Corps avoid double taxation — once at the corporate level and again at the individual level. The article, Should I Start an S Corp vs LLC for My Consulting Company?, provides an excellent insight into why some consultants might prefer the S Corp structure.

So, in essence, both LLCs and S Corps offer limited liability protection and have certain tax advantages. However, they differ significantly in management structure and operational flexibility. The question is: which one is right for you? Is it the simplicity and flexibility of an LLC, or the potential tax benefits and structured management of an S Corp? As a consultant or independent contractor, these are questions you'll want to explore before making your decision.

Comparing LLC and S Corp: Pros and Cons

Now that we've established what an LLC and an S Corp are, let's dive into a side-by-side comparison of the two. Understanding the pros and cons of each can be instrumental in guiding your decision.



  • Ease of formation: Starting an LLC is typically easier and less paperwork-intensive than forming an S Corp.
  • Management flexibility: LLCs offer more flexibility in management and operations, allowing you to run your business as you see fit.
  • Profit distribution: Unlike S Corps, which must adhere to strict distribution rules, LLCs can distribute profits to members as they see fit.


  • Self-employment taxes: LLC owners are considered self-employed and must pay self-employment tax on all business profits.
  • Limited growth potential: If you plan to expand your business significantly or seek outside investment, an LLC might limit your options.

S Corp:


  • Tax benefits: With an S Corp, only the salary paid to the owner-employee is subject to employment tax. The remaining income is paid to the owner as a "distribution," which is taxed at a lower rate.
  • Business credibility: Corporations, including S Corps, are often viewed as more professional and credible by clients and investors.


  • Strict requirements: S Corps have more stringent rules for operation, including required shareholder meetings and specific record-keeping requirements.
  • Limited ownership: S Corps can only have up to 100 shareholders, and all must be U.S. citizens or residents.

As you can see, both the LLC and S Corp structures have their own unique benefits and drawbacks. The LLC vs. S Corp: Which One is Right For Your? article provides a more in-depth look into these differences. Your choice between an LLC and S Corp will depend on your specific needs, goals, and circumstances.

Tax implications: LLC vs S Corp

When it comes to taxes, LLCs and S Corps are subject to different rules, and understanding these differences is crucial for your financial planning.

For LLCs, the IRS views them as pass-through entities. This means that all profits and losses are passed directly to the members, who then report this information on their personal tax returns. This can be both a blessing and a curse. On one hand, it simplifies tax reporting—there's no need to file a separate corporate tax return. However, it also means that LLC members are subject to self-employment taxes, which can be quite hefty.

S Corps, on the other hand, allow you to dodge the double taxation bullet. While they are also considered pass-through entities, there's a twist. As an S Corp owner, you can be both an employee and a shareholder of the company. This means you can pay yourself a "reasonable" salary, which is subject to employment tax, and then take the remaining profits as a distribution, which is not subject to self-employment tax. This can lead to substantial tax savings.

However, it's not all smooth sailing with S Corps. They have more stringent requirements, including a limit on the number of shareholders and restrictions on who can be a shareholder. Plus, the IRS keeps a close eye on S Corps to ensure that owners aren't underpaying themselves a salary to avoid employment taxes.

In his article, Why I Switched from 1099 to S Corp (and How It Impacted ..., Matt Olpinski details his personal journey of changing his business structure for tax reasons.

So, when it comes to taxes, which is better—an LLC or an S Corp? The answer, as with many things in life, is "it depends." It depends on your personal circumstances, your business goals, and your financial situation. It's always a good idea to consult with a trusted tax advisor before making this important decision.

Making the choice: Factors to consider for Independent Contractors and Consultants

So, you've got a handle on the basics of LLCs and S Corps, and you're starting to understand the tax implications of each. But how do you decide which is the right fit for you? This decision should be based on a careful consideration of your business needs, goals, and circumstances. Let's dive into some key factors you should consider:

  • Business Size and Structure: How big is your operation? How many employees do you have? If you're a one-person show, an LLC might be the simplest and most flexible option. But if you're planning on expanding, an S Corp might offer more growth potential.
  • Administrative Burden: Are you ready to handle the extra paperwork that comes with an S Corp? S Corps require regular board meetings, meeting minutes, and stockholder meetings. If this feels overwhelming, an LLC's less formal structure might be more your speed.
  • Future Plans: What are your long-term goals for your business? If you're planning on bringing in investors or selling your business down the line, an S Corp's structure might be more attractive.
  • Tax Considerations: We've already discussed this, but it's worth repeating. The potential tax savings of an S Corp can be significant, but they come with added complexity and scrutiny from the IRS.

Deciding between an LLC and an S Corp isn't a decision to be taken lightly. It's a choice that can have far-reaching implications for your business, your financial situation, and your peace of mind.

But don't worry, you're not alone in this. There are plenty of resources out there to help guide you. The article LLC vs. S Corp: Which One is Right For You? offers a detailed comparison of the two entity types, and Should I Start an S Corp vs LLC for My Consulting Company? provides an in-depth look at the pros and cons of each for consultants.

So take your time, do your research, and make the choice that feels right for you and your business.

Don't build
your independent business alone
Pollen helps you build your independent career through quality training, trusted mentors, and a powerful peer network.